Bitwarden vs. 1Password: Which password manager is better?

Tired of memorizing passwords and need an easier and safer way to log in? Learn how to manage them with autofill in this Bitwarden vs. 1Password comparison.

Struggling to memorize that one password you have changed a dozen times and still get locked out?

Try using a password manager. Two prominent ones are Bitwarden and 1Password. 

Bitwarden offers a free, open-source platform, while 1Password delivers advanced password management. However, which provides better password security?

Let’s find out in this Bitwarden vs. 1Password comparison.

Bitwarden vs. 1Password: At a Glance

Here is a table breaking down the factors we considered in this Bitwarden vs. 1Password comparison.

Criteria	Bitwarden	1Password	Winner
SMB Guide’s Rating	8.4/10	8.5/10	1Password
Multi-factor Security and Authentication	✅	✅	Bitwarden
One-time Passwords	✅	✅	Tie
Password Capture and Generation	✅	✅	1Password
Password Sharing	✅	✅	1Password
Emergency Access	✅	✅	1Password
Security Dashboard	✅	✅	1Password
Account Recovery	✅	✅	1Password
Browser Extensions	✅	✅	Bitwarden
Data Privacy and Compliance	✅	✅	Tie
User Experience and User Interface	Easy to use	Feature-rich interface	1Password
Integrations and Compatibility	✅	✅	Bitwarden
Customer Support	Email; live chat; DIY	Forum, X (Twitter), and email	Tie
Pricing	Free – $6	$2.99/mo – $7.99/mo	Bitwarden
Scalability	✅	✅	Bitwarden

Bitwarden: Key Features, Pros, Cons, & Pricing

Bitwarden is a password manager that offers a free, highly secure, open-source platform. In addition to providing basic functions like secure note storage and autofill for free, users can access premium features. 

They include emergency access, organization storage, biometric logins, and more, costing $10 annually. No other free password manager offers a feature stack as stellar as Bitwarden’s at that price.

Pros & Cons

Pricing

Bitwarden categorizes its pricing into two: Personal and Business. Personal is a package for individuals and families. It also has three scalable plans, including a forever-free package.

The free plan offers a stellar stack of features, including passkey management and unlimited device support. 

Paid plans provide advanced capabilities like integrated authenticator and emergency access. The good thing is that users get a money-back guarantee of 30 days on the paid plans and a week-long free trial period.

The billing cycle is annual, and here are the plans:

• Free: $0
• Premium: $10 annually
• Families: $40 annually

1Password: Key Features, Pros, Cons, & Pricing

1Password is a password manager that excels at offering password organization systems, MFA, and more. Users will find the software offers core functions like password autofill across unlimited devices and document storage. 

Not only that, 1Password provides advanced features like multiple vaults, travel mode, and watchtower security check.  It also offers cross-platform support, making it suit Android and iOS users.

Pros & Cons

Pricing

1Password pricing structure is straightforward, offering 4 scalable plans. The plans lack a free package, but users get a free trial period of 14 days after subscription.

The billing cycle is annual, and it includes a dedicated Business plan.

Here are the plans:

• Individual: $35.88 annually
• Families: $59.88 annually
• Team Starter Pack: $239.40 annually
• Business: $95.88 annually

Multi-Factor Security and Authentication

Bitwarden provides a broad selection of MFA options, including standard methods like email and SMS in the free plan. It also includes Authenticator apps like Google, Authy, and Bitwarden, which are available on free and paid plans.

Users will also find hardware tokens like Yubikey, which are available only on paid plans.

1Password also provides MFA options, including Authenticator apps like Authy, Google, and Okta Verify. It also offers hardware tools like YubiKey and Titan.

Bitwarden simplifies the process of setting up the MFA options. Users can scan and use a QR code with their authenticator app or through the Bitwarden web app.

1Password also offers a simple MFA setup. Users log in to their accounts and follow the prompts. However, the process is more involved than it is on Bitwarden.

Although Bitwarden and 1Password offer a wide range of MFAs, some MFA methods offer the best security. For example, hardware tokens like YubiKey and Titan provide the strongest resilience against phishing because of their physical nature. 

Authenticator Apps offer a good balance of convenience and security. They generate unique codes every few seconds, preventing them from becoming prone to phishing attacks.

Email and SMS are the least secure than the other two, making them susceptible to sim swap and phishing.

✅ Winner: Bitwarden

One-Time Passwords

Bitwarden has a built-in authenticator that allows users to generate six-digit-based TOTPs using SHA-1. The process is simple, and the OTPs expire in 30 seconds.

Bitwarden also allows users to create TOTPs through a QR code scan or by manually keying a secret code.

Like Bitwarden, 1Password also offers an authenticator for generating TOTPs with a single tap. The process is simple: Users can save the OTPs within the app, scan a QR code, or enter a string of characters.

On integration, Bitwarden connects seamlessly with mobile apps and websites that support OTPs. Users will find that the browser extension auto-fills the TOTPs automatically and simplifies copying and pasting on the clipboard.

1Password integration depends on enabling 2FA to store and access OTPs quickly on websites and mobile apps. However, like Bitwarden, it auto-fills them automatically after the username and password for seamless logging.

Regarding security features, Bitwarden supports storing keys for OTP generation on free and paid accounts. However, generating the code is only available for paid plans.

Bitwarden also provides a ‘Bitwarden Send ‘ feature for securing end-to-end data sharing.

1Password, on the other hand, generates its TOTPs to be compatible with traditional passwords. It adds a layer of protection for activities like changing passwords or online shopping.

✅ Winner: 1Password

Password Capture and Generation

Bitwarden offers a browser extension that facilitates password capture. The extension can automatically detect login info from browsers and import them. It can also import passwords from other password managers in formats like CSV.

Like Bitwarden, 1Password has a browser extension that can capture passwords from browsers and import them automatically. The extension can also import login info from other password managers in various formats, like CSV.

However, 1Password has an edge with its ‘Watchtower’ feature, which helps scan the dark web for compromised data.

With password generation, Bitwarden can create random and strong passwords based on set criteria. Users can customize their password length (up to 128 characters), add symbols, and use upper- and lower-case letters. 

It also allows users to save custom password templates for use on other sites. However, unlike 1Password, Bitwarden lacks a username generation feature.

Like Bitwarden, 1Password generates random and strong passwords that are customizable. Users can set criteria for customizing password length (up to 64 characters), add upper and lowercase letters, and more.

However, unlike Bitwarden, users can generate usernames alongside passwords, creating a unique logging combination.

✅ Winner: 1Password

Password Sharing

Bitwarden provides password sharing permissions through collection and organization structures. It allows users to move their items (folders) to an organization for easy access by other users. 

Through it, an owner can create organization folders for sharing. Users can set it to allow read-only or full editing capability when sharing.

1Password, on the other hand, offers more granular password sharing permissions. Users can create shared vaults and manage who gets access to them. From there, a user can provide full editing access or read-only. 

The best part is that 1Password offers the Watchtower function for shared passwords. It helps to notify an owner when a shared password appears in a data breach.

On security measures, Bitwarden uses end-to-end encryption in transit and at rest. Bitwarden also adds a one-time OTP for extra protection. 

1Password uses a unique link system for sharing. The software encrypts the data with a shared secret and decrypts it when it reaches a recipient. Users can also set expiry dates on the shared links for added protection.

With audit trails, Bitwarden offers limited log trails for password sharing. The only info available to users is who accessed a password and when.

1Password offers detailed audit trails for password sharing. An owner can view who accessed the password, the timing, and the actions performed.

✅ Winner: 1Password

Emergency Access

The Bitwarden emergency access process is straightforward. A user invites contacts by email and specifies their access level. Then, if the contact doesn’t have a user account, they create one and accept the invitation that includes a public key.

Something to note is that the contact has five days to accept the invite.

1Password offers a printable emergency kit containing master password hints or designated contacts.

A user can then share the emergency kit details with contacts, who should accept them using a secret key. 1Password includes the emergency access feature on Teams and Families plans.

On security measures, Bitwarden uses public key cryptography for encrypted communication. It ensures only a designated contact with a private key can access the vault.

1Password also uses secret keys for designated contacts. It also adds MFA for extra protection when accessing the emergency kit.

With revoking and modifying access, Bitwarden allows users to remove a contact at any time. The contact gets notified about the removal, and they lose access to the vault.

Unlike Bitwarden, 1Password offers more flexibility. At any moment, a user can revoke or edit a contact’s access to the emergency kit.

✅ Winner: 1Password

Security Dashboard

Bitwarden provides a security dashboard displaying a vault health report on weak, reused, compromised, and exposed passwords.

Not only that, it identifies items in a vault without active 2FA. However, unlike 1Password, it lacks granular capabilities like data breach monitoring.

1Password offers a more comprehensive security dashboard than Bitwarden. Users can view their weak, reused passwords and security alerts for breaches.

Not only that, but 1Password offers a Watchtower feature that provides advanced breach alerts. 

It monitors the dark web for any compromised emails and provides in-depth information and remedial steps to follow.

On customization, 1Password allows users to customize the dashboard for specific security metrics. Bitwarden, on the other hand, lacks advanced customization options.

With usability, the Bitwarden dashboard is simple but has limited functionality. 1Password offers users a richer experience that enhances usability, which facilitates better decision-making.

✅ Winner: 1Password

Account Recovery

Users will find that Bitwarden provides account recovery only for enterprises. The software allows designated users to recover accounts when employees lose the master password.

The recovery process is simple. It starts with a user’s encryption key getting decrypted using the organization’s private key.

The key then gets encrypted again with the new master key and a password. One thing to note is that Bitwarden provides a recovery code that bypasses a two-step login.

With backup mechanisms, Bitwarden doesn’t offer any built-in options. However, the software allows exporting an encrypted user’s vault to an external storage.

1Password uses a powerful account recovery system similar to Bitwarden. It uses a secret key created when signing up and an emergency kit.

Something to note is that the printable emergency kit contains information for recovering an account without the secret key. 

1Password also allows owners to designate emergency contacts to recipients who can provide access in case of incapacitation. The handy approach leaves no room for redundancy.

On backup, 1Password offers cloud storage or local file backups for data, unlike Bitwarden. The backups get encrypted with a user’s master password, adding a layer of protection.

✅ Winner: 1Password

Browser Extensions

Bitwarden provides excellent password capture, autofill, and generation functionality. It also provides a browser extension that is compatible with most browsers. They include Tor, Google, Firefox, Brave, Vivaldi, Edge, Safari, and Opera browsers.

The extension offers more features than 1Password, like saving logins, creating folders, generating passwords, and autofill. Not only that, users can log on to five accounts on Bitwarden at the same time, unlike on 1Password.

With security measures, Bitwarden uses end-to-end encryption, even when transmitting data through Bitwarden Send. However, Bitwarden limitation is in the extra clicks required within the extension to access the features.

1Password provides excellent password capture, autofill, and generation functionality similar to Bitwarden. It also integrates with standard browsers: Google, Firefox, Brave, Edge, Safari, Opera, and Brave.

However, it lacks compatibility with Tor and Vivaldi, unlike Bitwarden. 1Password also uses local encryption and a secret key that never leaves a user’s device. It is an approach that provides transparency and control over password protection.

✅ Winner: Bitwarden

Data Privacy and Compliance

Bitwarden uses AES-256 encryption to secure data at rest and in transit. The software also employs TLS 1.2 to secure data when transmitting between users and servers.

For data management, Bitwarden uses a zero-knowledge architecture, ensuring the user’s vault stays secure and private. 

Bitwarden complies with GDPR, CCPA, HIPAA, and Privacy Shield guidelines. The platform also has certifications under SOC-2 and 3. It is also a member of the FIDO alliance.

The best part is that the open-source nature allows extra scrutiny from the public for overall transparency.

Like Bitwarden, 1Password uses industry-standard AES-256 encryption but with a PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA256 key. It also employs TLS 1.2 for data security when transmitting between users and servers.

With data storage, 1Password stores its data in multiple data centers globally. A user can pick a 1Password data center based on preference or proximity.

1Password also uses zero-knowledge technology. It means the data is secure, and no one, including the authorities, can access it.

On compliance, 1Password adheres to CCPA and GDPR. The software has also undergone an audit by third-party companies (Recurity Labs and Secfault Security). Not only that, 1Password has certification under SOC 2 Type II.

✅ Winner: Tie

User Interface and User Experience

Users will find the Bitwarden interface more technical, which can intimidate beginners. The interface uses a vault structure for data storage but provides a granular organization.

Navigating the platform is a bit overwhelming and requires exploring to get a hang of it.

On customization, Bitwarden offers basic options. Users can only modify the themes and the vault view to a list or grid.

On the other hand, 1Password offers a feature-rich interface with cross-platform support. The platform has a steeper learning curve and looks cluttered.

Navigating the dashboard is easier compared to Bitwarden. The good thing is that it provides a broader range of customization options than Bitwarden.

1Password allows users to organize items with favorites and tags. Users can also adjust settings, personalize layouts, and choose themes.

✅ Winner: 1Password

Integrations and Compatibility

Bitwarden offers an open-source platform compatible with major OSs, including Windows 10+, Linux, Android, iOS, and macOS 10+. 

Unlike 1Password, Bitwarden provides more applications, including a mobile app, browser extension, desktop app, and web app for most browsers. The extension integrates with Tor, Chrome, Firefox, Opera, Brave, Linux, Vivaldi, Safari, and Edge.

Bitwarden also supports Azure Active Directory for user management and HRIS. Not only that, it integrates with email forwarding services for improved protection and privacy.

Like 1Password, Bitwarden has a public API that organizations can use to manage collections, groups, and event logs.

1Password is compatible with major OSs like Linux, Android, Windows, iOS, and macOS. It also provides an extension that integrates with browsers like Edge, Brave, Chrome, Safari, Opera, Brave, and Firefox.

One thing to note is that 1Password offers a Connect Server API that allows access to the software’s vaults. Whether within a company’s cloud or app infrastructure. It can include SDK libraries for existing app integration and more.

✅ Winner: Bitwarden

Customer Support

Bitwarden offers only three customer support options: Tickets, Forum, and Email. Unlike most password managers, it lacks live chat and phone support. Response times on the tickets are 24 hours, but on the community forum, replies are quicker depending on the issue.

The support agents help resolve complex issues. They understand technical problems.

Users looking for self-help resources will find that Bitwarden offers a resource center, blog, and documentation. The content is comprehensive and covers topics related to the software’s inner workings.

1Password also offers support through a forum, X (Twitter), and email. Like Bitwarden, it lacks live chat support.

However, the support agents are responsive and offer satisfactory, comprehensive replies. The agents also address technical issues with expertise, offering an enjoyable experience. 

Users looking for self-help resources will find that 1Password offers a podcast, webinars, and a newsletter. The content is high-quality and thorough enough to solve complex issues.

✅ Winner: Tie

Pricing

Unlike 1Password, Bitwarden offers three plans, including a free package. The free package is feature-rich, offering unlimited sync across devices and more.

Bitwarden paid plans start at $10, billed annually. These plans offer advanced features like priority support and an integrated authenticator at a lower cost.

Bitwarden also offers a money-back guarantee of 30 days and dedicated business plans for enterprise-size organizations.

1Password, on the other hand, offers four plans without a free package. The plans start at $35.88, billed annually, and provide premium features like travel mode.

Unlike Bitwarden, 1Password lacks a money-back guarantee but includes a free trial period of 14 days.

The lack of a free plan lowers its value proposition, even though it includes a free trial period. The individual plans are also higher than those of Bitwarden.

✅ Winner: Bitwarden

Scalability

Bitwarden focuses on security with scalability. Its integration with Azure allows it to host many users and devices.

It ensures scalability, uptime, and timely management of security updates. The best part is that its tech stack can support high-performance and growth-fitting businesses of all sizes.

1Password offers unlimited device support to its users. However, unlike Bitwarden, it limits its plans to a maximum of ten users (Teams plan). It poses scalability limitations, especially for businesses or families with many users.

✅ Winner: Bitwarden

Standout Features of Bitwarden

Bitwarden focus on security and scalability at an affordable price makes it one of the standout open-source password managers today. Here are three features we found that make it unique.

• Bitwarden Send – Users who run businesses collaborating by sharing sensitive data will find this feature valuable. It allows a user to transmit encrypted data securely to other parties quickly.
• Local Data Hosting – Self-hosting is a welcome add-on, especially for users who deal with sensitive information. Bitwarden allows such users to use local data hosting, giving them complete control over their data management.
• Open Source Platform – Bitwarden offers an open-source code base that anyone can review, contribute to, and audit. It is a feature that transcends transparency, a crucial requirement for security software.

Standout Features of 1Password

Besides helping users organize their passwords through its excellent apps, 1Passowrd offers more than basic functionality. We found three features during our evaluation that make it stand out.

• Passkey Support – They offer a modern, faster, and securely passwordless way of signing on. Passkeys get stored on trusted devices like smartphones and protected by biometrics or device PIN.
• Email Masking – It is a way of using anonymous email when conducting online business, like shopping. It helps protect a user’s actual email by creating masked addresses that help avoid monitoring or data breaches.
• Travel Mode – Users can secure their sensitive data when traveling through the travel mode. The feature removes password access, making it accessible only through a secret passkey.

Bitwarden vs. 1Password: SMB Guide’s Verdict

Our Bitwarden vs 1Password comparison shows that both password managers offer different plans with different features. Picking one will depend on your budget, needs, and preferences.

However, after evaluating both of them, 1Password is the winner. Here is why:

1Password offers premium features like travel mode, a watchtower, and an emergency kit that beefs security.

The platform also offers a seamless browser extension and a polished interface. All these and more are the reasons it narrowly wins this comparison.

Bitwarden is an ideal alternative, offering an open-source platform with a broad range of MFAs. It also includes a free plan and supports a more comprehensive range of browser extensions (8+).

However, the lack of advanced core features and complex interface make it lose this comparison.

Choose 1Password If:

You need an advanced password manager offering comprehensive security features at a premium.

Choose Bitwarden If:

You value open-source platforms that offer free self-hosting options.